Fee-only vs. fee-based vs. commission
| Model | Compensation | Conflict level |
|---|---|---|
| Fee-only | Paid only by the client — AUM, flat, or hourly | Low |
| Fee-based | Client fees + commissions/trails from products sold | Mixed |
| Commission | Paid by product sponsors when you buy | High |
The word that matters is only. 'Fee-based' is a marketing label that includes commission revenue; 'fee-only' does not.
Why fee-only matters
- No incentive to recommend annuities, loaded mutual funds, or proprietary products that pay the advisor.
- No 12b-1 or revenue-sharing kickbacks influencing the fund lineup.
- Compensation is visible on a single line of your statement, not buried in fund expense ratios.
How fee-only advisors charge
- Assets under management (AUM): 0.50%–1.25%/yr with breakpoints.
- Flat annual planning fee: $3,000–$15,000/yr.
- Hourly: $250–$500/hr for one-time engagements.
- Project-based: typically $2,500–$10,000 for a defined deliverable.
How to verify fee-only status
What fee-only does not guarantee
Fee-only removes commission conflicts but does not eliminate every conflict. AUM-based firms still have an incentive to grow assets under management — which can subtly discourage paying down a mortgage, gifting, or buying an annuity even when those moves serve the client. The best way to manage this conflict is to expect — and ask for — analysis on every option, including options that reduce AUM.
Stephen Arnold
Founder & CEO of Wealth Protection Advisory. Pension and retirement planner with 20+ years advising small business owners. Creator of the Designer DB Plus® strategy and author of Designer DB Plus® Game-Changing Tax Reduction & Retirement Strategy.
