§401(h) Account vs. HSA: Which Is Better for Retiree Medical?

7 min read

Both the §401(h) account and the Health Savings Account (HSA) deliver tax-free retiree medical dollars, but they sit at very different scales and play very different roles in a business owner's plan.

Annual contribution capacity

The 2025 HSA family limit is $8,550 (plus a $1,000 catch-up at 55). A §401(h) sub-account inside a DB plan can absorb up to 25% of cumulative aggregate DB contributions — for a practice contributing $300,000/year to a cash balance plan, that is roughly $75,000/year of additional medical-purpose deduction.

Effect of Medicare enrollment

Medicare enrollment ends HSA contributions. A §401(h) account is unaffected — contributions, growth, and distributions all continue normally for the retiree and spouse.

Use beyond medical

An HSA can be used for non-medical purposes after 65 (taxable as ordinary income). A §401(h) cannot — funds must be used for qualified retiree medical, or they revert to the plan.

Estate and beneficiary treatment

An HSA passes to a spouse tax-free but is fully taxable to a non-spouse heir. A §401(h) does not pass as an inheritable asset; unused balances revert to the plan per the document's terms.

When each one fits

An HSA is the right starting point for nearly every household with HDHP coverage. A §401(h) is layered on top when a business already runs a cash balance plan and the owners want to convert pre-retirement income into post-retirement tax-free medical capacity.

Educational only. This page is for general education on §401(h) accounts and qualified retirement plan design. It is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Consult a qualified fiduciary advisor, enrolled actuary, and ERISA counsel before adopting a §401(h) sub-account.
FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I have both an HSA and a §401(h)?

Yes. They are not mutually exclusive. Most owner candidates fund both.

Which has the bigger deduction?

§401(h) by an order of magnitude — typical capacity is $50,000–$100,000+ per year vs. an HSA family limit of $8,550.

Which is better for a non-spouse heir?

An HSA, with caveats — it is fully taxable to a non-spouse heir, while a §401(h) reverts to the plan.